Did Tanagaki Get Setup In Golden Kamuy

Liam Oliver Theodore

2 min read

·

04-12-2024

22

0

Share

The question of whether Tanigaki was set up in Golden Kamuy is a complex one, lacking a definitive yes or no answer. While the series doesn't explicitly state a deliberate plot to frame him, the circumstances surrounding his predicament strongly suggest a degree of manipulation and unfortunate coincidence that worked against him.

The Evidence Suggesting a Setup

Several points within the narrative contribute to the argument that Tanigaki's situation wasn't purely coincidental:

• The timing of the discovery: The discovery of the bodies and the subsequent accusations against Tanigaki are suspiciously convenient for those seeking to eliminate him or shift blame. The timing could have been manipulated, perhaps by someone with foreknowledge of his movements.

• Lack of concrete evidence: The evidence linking Tanigaki directly to the murders is circumstantial at best. While suspicion is raised, the lack of irrefutable proof raises questions about the thoroughness of the investigation, hinting at possible interference or deliberate omission of exculpatory evidence.

• Suspiciously convenient witnesses: The testimony of witnesses could be unreliable, potentially swayed by external pressures or misinformation. Their statements might be colored by biases, or manipulated to incriminate Tanigaki.

• Underlying motives: Powerful individuals or factions would benefit from Tanigaki's downfall. Their actions, either directly or indirectly, could have contributed to the circumstances surrounding the accusations, even if not orchestrated as a direct "setup."

The Argument Against a Deliberate Setup

Conversely, arguments against a direct setup exist:

• Tanigaki's past: Tanigaki's violent past and reputation could have contributed to the speed and harshness of judgment. The assumption of guilt due to past actions is a possible explanation.

• Coincidence: The events leading to the accusations, while suspicious, could be a series of unfortunate coincidences and misinterpretations. This scenario aligns with the chaotic and unpredictable nature of the Golden Kamuy world.

• Lack of definitive proof: The series, intentionally or not, provides no smoking gun pointing to a deliberate setup. Speculation is possible, but conclusive proof is lacking.

Conclusion

Ultimately, whether Tanigaki was "set up" remains a matter of interpretation. The narrative strongly implies manipulation and circumstantial evidence working against him, but the series doesn't offer a conclusive answer. The ambiguity is part of the story's complexity, leaving readers to draw their own conclusions based on the presented evidence and their interpretation of the characters' motivations. The narrative leans towards suggesting a degree of manipulation, however, leaving a lingering question mark that adds to the suspense and intrigue of the story.